# UFO's and Defense: What Should We Prepare For (COMETA file)

> This PURSUE Release 01 PDF under NASA holdings packages the independent French COMETA association report UFOs and Defense: What Should We Prepare For? (late 1990s) plus related correspondence including a Carol Rosin letter. Archival storage in a NASA-indexed file is not NASA authorship.

- Canonical: https://anomalywiki.com/official-records/government-file/nasa-ufo-defense-what-should-we-prepare-for/
- Section: Official records
- Last reviewed: 2026-10-02

## Mainstream view

COMETA is a well-known late-1990s French independent/semi-official-adjacent study often cited in UFO literature; mainstream national-security writing treats it as advocacy and analysis by a private association, not as settled NATO/U.S. doctrine.

## Why this packet confuses people

A PDF that sits in NASA holdings and argues UFOs deserve serious defense attention is easy to misread as “NASA confirms.” The PURSUE Release 01 file instead packages COMETA’s late-1990s independent report - previously published in the French magazine VDS in 1999 - plus correspondence. COMETA discusses the extraterrestrial hypothesis among other analyses and urges preparedness; that is the association’s case, not a U.S. finding that hostile craft require a specific American force posture.

The Rosin letter of 30 April 2001 is personal correspondence in the same packet. It is not White House policy and should not be inflated into a secret disclosure plan.

## Citation hygiene

Quote COMETA for what COMETA argued. Quote [AARO Volume I](https://anomalywiki.com/official-records/government-file/aaro-historical-record-report-vol-1/) for later U.S. historical conclusions. Keep NASA stills such as [STS-80 D031](https://anomalywiki.com/official-records/government-file/nasa-uap-d031-sts-80-unidentified-object/) on their own media lane. Portal browsing and Release 01 context live on the [PURSUE hub](https://anomalywiki.com/official-records/archive-collection/pursue-war-gov-ufo/) and [announcements](https://anomalywiki.com/official-records/release-batch/pursue-release-announcements/).

## Claims vs mainstream view

- **Claim:** NASA released this because NASA agrees UFOs are alien threats. **Mainstream:** PURSUE publishes holdings; agency tag is custody, not endorsement.
- **Claim:** COMETA is the official French Defense Ministry white paper. **Mainstream:** Cite COMETA as an independent association report linked to IHEDN circles - not as binding MoD doctrine without primary MoD attribution.
- **Claim:** The Rosin/von Braun letter proves a secret alien disclosure plan. **Mainstream:** The letter is personal correspondence in the packet - do not inflate into official policy.

## FAQ

### Did NASA write this report?

No. The index describes an independent COMETA report held in a NASA-associated file package released under PURSUE.

### Is COMETA the official French Defense Ministry white paper?

Treat it as an independent association study linked to IHEDN circles. Do not upgrade it to binding MoD doctrine without a primary MoD attribution.

### Why is Carol Rosin’s letter included?

The packet includes her 30 April 2001 letter transmitting materials in a space-advocacy context and referencing her role as spokesperson for Wernher von Braun in his later years.

### Does publication mean NASA agrees UFOs are alien threats?

No. Agency tags in PURSUE often mark custody. Cite COMETA’s arguments as COMETA’s, not as NASA policy.

### How should U.S. readers balance this with AARO?

COMETA is late-1990s French independent analysis/advocacy. AARO Volume I is a 2024 U.S. historical assessment - cite each for what it is.

## Sources

- [255_413270 PDF (War.gov)](https://www.war.gov/medialink/ufo/release_1/255_413270_ufo's_and_defense_what_should_we_prepare_for.pdf) - U.S. Department of War / NASA holdings
