Separate the voyage from the ideology and Thule splits cleanly into two stories that happen to share a name. The first is a real, if frustratingly incomplete, classical geography puzzle. Around 325 BCE, the Greek explorer Pytheas of Massalia sailed north from the Mediterranean, apparently reaching or circling Britain, and reported continuing six more days to an island he called Thule, near a sea he described as frozen or "solidified." His own written account did not survive antiquity; everything known about it comes filtered through later writers who quote him selectively, often specifically to dispute him.
Strabo, writing a few centuries later, calls Pytheas an "arch-falsifier" over his claims about Britain's size and distances, and extends that distrust to Thule - yet Strabo also notes, almost as a backhanded compliment, that no other ancient writer who actually reached Britain mentions Thule at all, which some modern historians read as a sign Pytheas uniquely sailed far enough to encounter it. Pliny the Elder, writing a century after Strabo, treats the identity question as already unsettled in his own day, cataloging competing proposals: Iceland, the Faroe Islands, Norway's Thylemark region, Shetland, or Scandinavia broadly. Modern classicists have not resolved what Pliny couldn't - Iceland remains the most commonly favored candidate, but the case is probabilistic, not closed.
Virgil complicated things further without trying to geolocate anything at all. His 19 BCE line about "ultima Thule" in the Georgics uses the name as a figure of speech for the world's farthest edge, not a place reference - a usage that outlived the geography question itself and let "Thule" drift loose from any specific coordinates in later literature.
That drift is exactly what made Thule available for repurposing in 1918, when Rudolf von Sebottendorff founded the Thule Society in Munich. The society had nothing to do with Pytheas's reported voyage; it borrowed the name for an invented "Hyperborean" homeland of a supposedly superior ancient race, folding in earlier Theosophical root-race mythology and incubating a membership that overlapped with early Nazi party figures. SS-sponsored expeditions later searching for Aryan origins found no trace of any such civilization, because the Thule Society's Hyperborea was ideological invention from the start, built on borrowed vocabulary rather than borrowed geography. For the Theosophical root-race material that fed directly into this strand, see Hyperborea and Lemuria; for other sunken or vanished homelands recruited into 20th-century myth-making, see Atlantis theories and Mu.
